Booking takes away our phone, Airbnb the house rules: what changes for hotels and short-term rentals

Booking and Airbnb have each done something lately: Booking took away the guest's phone number that used to land in our PMS, and Airbnb changed the house rules. The truth is, we sort of deserve it.
We are losing two very important things we took for granted. The guest's phone number in our management system, and with it the freedom to send them information. And, as far as Airbnb goes, the freedom to tell a guest in our own home what they can and can't do. Rules that come from arguments the public has found fair.
What changes with Booking and Airbnb
Here is what happened, in detail. Since 28 September, Booking has stopped passing the phone number to our management systems, our channel managers and every connected tool. The number is still visible in the extranet, but the consequence is that to write to the guest we are left with Booking's chat and the masked email.
On 20 October, Airbnb completely rewrote its house rules. It will apply to all bookings from 20 November, and the real rules will be 7: they cover the maximum number of guests, locking up on departure and little else. Everything else is a request from us, and from now on the request has to be reasonable.
For example, we can ask guests to leave the dishes in the sink, but not to wash them. We can ask them to gather the towels in one spot, but not to strip the beds. To sort the recycling, but not to carry the bags out to the bins.
Anyone who doesn't comply will find a notice in their listing along the lines of "includes cleaning requests", and the guest will see it while deciding where to book. And rules can no longer be added in messages or on signs hung in the house.
Why Booking took away the phone number
Booking said it will no longer give us the phone number in order to protect guests from WhatsApp scams. That is partly true, because this year a lot of our guests' data was stolen around Europe, and guests were then asked for details to "verify" their card, or hit with similar scams.
That data also leaked out of our own systems. Weak passwords, insecure management systems, or systems we ourselves opened up to suppliers and forgot about the next day. Every one of those accesses increased the chance of it being stolen.
But to me this story isn't entirely true. In April, for example, the breach was in Booking's systems, not ours. And this is a choice that suits Booking quite well, because from now on the first conversation with the guest necessarily goes through its chat, where Booking sees everything and decides what a message may contain. Here security and control coincide, and I don't think that's by chance.
Of course, if we had been more careful and kept our data cleaner, we'd probably have an argument to complain with today. Which we don't.
Why, as a hotelier, I'm not celebrating Airbnb's rules
I'm a hotelier and I could be happy about Airbnb's move, which in a way puts limits on hosts. We know there is friction between hotels and non-hotel accommodation. But truth be told, I'm not happy.
It's another clear signal. Airbnb has also opened up to hotels, starting with twenty cities including Rome, and is turning into a proper OTA. The new rules are another way to get even more control and be even more jealous of its guests, putting itself more and more between us, the properties, hotel or non-hotel, and our customers.
What changes for those who run short-term rentals
There are two details that weigh more than the dishes we can't have washed. Airbnb doesn't allow hosts to ask for documents, unless the law requires it. In Italy, fortunately or unfortunately, the law does require it, but it has to be declared clearly in the listing, and there will most likely be conflicts.
Moreover, the host can no longer force the guest to register on an external app to get in and do self check-in. In Italy the law already didn't provide for this, but now it is explicitly stated on the platform.
What hotels can do now
If you have a WhatsApp assistant, like me, or a system that sends messages before arrival, you have probably already found out: for people who book on Booking, that message no longer goes out. No error at all. The guest simply doesn't receive it.
The countermove can be this: the first message to guests goes out from Booking's chat and contains the link to online check-in, where the guest can leave their number knowing what it's for.
Copying and pasting the phone numbers of Booking reservations into the management system strikes me as a little more complicated. We are trying to automate all of these processes, and here we are taking a step back. And then there is always the consent rule: if the guest hasn't given us permission to use their number and then complains, they're right.
Direct contact is not inherited
For years the phone number arrived systematically, for free, or rather included in the commission we pay Booking, inside a field of the management system filled in by someone else. We always treated it as ours and built welcome messages, door codes and dinner offers on top of it.
On these pages Silvia Moggia described how Booking is betting everything on traveller trust. The vanishing phone number and the sign to take down in the kitchen are the practical way that trust is administered, managed and consolidated by the platform, and not by us.
For the contact that remains ours, then, one more step is needed: it is only what the guest has left us after we have explained what we need it for. In the coming months there is one number to watch in our properties: how many Booking guests leave it to us in the online check-in.
Originally published in Italian by Michele Passalacqua on Officina Turistica. Translation preserves the author's original voice.
Read the original (Italian)